The two biggest names on the trade market come off the board
On Saturday it was announced that the Columbus Blue Jackets had traded disgruntled young star Pierre-Luc Dubois (and a draft pick) to the Winnipeg Jets for similarly disgruntled young star Patrik Laine (and Jack Roslovic).
On Friday, I wrote an article stating that Dubois was worth pursuing because of his potential to add a high-end second center who was only 22 years old, but I also acknowledged that he was more likely to be swapped to a team who could offer a comparable high-end player in return (instead of a decent package that Canes could put together). That is pretty much what happened on Saturday likely without the Hurricanes every really being in the mix.
During the course of the off-season, the Hurricanes were also linked to Patrik Laine in the rumor mill. While acknowledging his high ceiling as an elite scorer, I was never a fan of adding Laine because his game is a bit one-dimensional and because of the salary cap issues with needing to re-sign him next summer. I wrote about Laine HERE.
At least for now, that takes at least the publicly available high-end players off the market.
There were also rumblings during the off-season that the Hurricanes could be in the market for a goalie upgrade.
Do the Hurricanes still need to add one or two higher-end players to take a next step?
For me, that raises the question — Do the Hurricanes still need a higher-end player or two to take a next step up from being a playoff regular to truly being an elite team with better than the ‘every playoff team gets a dice roll’ chance of winning the Stanley Cup?
I am torn on that question.
I rode the fence a bit on the goalie situation saying that I did think the Hurricanes should at least consider adding a goalie with a higher ceiling, but at the same time I said that an upgrade was not a necessity.
I liked Dubois but not Laine.
I wrote articles from a couple different angles stating that having a second scoring line emerge around Vincent Trocheck or someone else centering the second line could be the single most important thing for improving in 2020-21.
I do strongly believe that the team needs to improve in terms of having a second scoring line to back up Aho’s. But the trickier part is whether that requires help from outside or whether enough gains can be made internally.
Can Vincent Trocheck produce at a level somewhere between his 75-point peak and the 50-point pace he posted in 2019-20, and is that enough?
Could Martin Necas be part of the answer either supporting Trocheck as a finishing wing or even moving back to the center position like Aho did after gaining a bit more experience?
Or do the Canes really just need to opportunistically find a deal to add one more difference-maker via trade?
Where do I land?
I do think the Hurricanes need probably two more higher-end scorers to take a next step. The NHL’s top teams tend to be two lines deep in terms of scoring, so it can be hard to compete with them in the playoffs, especially on the road, without being able to match them. But I do not necessarily think that such help must come from outside the organization. If Martin Necas continues to grow and finds chemistry with Trocheck, that could instandly be 2/3 of that needed second scoring line. Especially if Brind’Amour separates Svechnikov from Aho’s line like he has mostly done so far, that could make the Hurricanes two lines deep offensively maybe even without it being clear which is the first line.
So based on the fact that Necas is really only in his second NHL season at the young age of 22 and that Trocheck had sort of a shot and odd set of auditions in 2019-20 with the COVID-19 effects, I would be fine with giving the duo some time to see one or both of them is the answer. But at the point where that does not look promising after a longer look, I would become a bit more interested in trying to do a deal to add one more high-end player.
I think people can overestimate how long a window is certain to be open for a rising young team like the Hurricanes. The challenges of re-signing good young players makes it difficult to keep a good team intact. And statistics seem to show that players’ primes are younger than some think anyway.
So when I net it out, I lean toward having a bit of patience to see what the team has in Martin Necas and Vincent Trocheck. If that does not look to be a path to a higher-end second scoring line, I would more aggressively be a bidder the next time a high-end forward becomes available.
What say you Canes fans?
1) Knowing that young, top line type players like Dubois and Laine do not hit the trade market often, do you think the Hurricanes should have more aggressively pursued one or both of them?
2) Do you think the Hurricanes still need to add a higher-end player or two from outside to take another step forward into the top echelon of the NHL?
Go Canes!
The biggest thing the Canes could land to take another step forward is a top tier goalie. Mrazek is fine, but no one is confusing him with the best in the league. Maybe he’ll find another level like Khudobin did last year in Dallas, who by the way look really good.
I don’t think Trocheck needs to score 75 points to be a big plus for the Canes. 50-60 points would be a big increase at the 2C position and a step in the right direction.
The Canes do need Svechnikov and Necas to keep developing. Love the way Svechnikov played in his last 4 periods. Necas still has a long way to go. He is still a perimeter player, but he is still young and has a chance to become more.
Getting a high end player from outside the organization has costs. I had zero interest in Dubois, but it would have cost the Canes a top player which would have been a wash anyway. The Canes best hope is one of their draft picks is the real deal.
BTW…what is up in Colomubus? Dubois said it wasn’t Torts. I get that Columbus isn’t a very cosmopolitan city, but Winnipeg? Woof. Something is up with that team.
I’m torn too, though I feel a bit better about it given that Trocheck, Nino, Dzingle, and Gardiner are off to better starts and we haven’t even really heard from Dougie or Teuvo yet. And our Mrazek/Reimer combo has been very good early.
I’m fine being patient.
1. No. Neither player is “character guy” and RBA and Waddell have talked about wanting only character guys on the team. And I agree neither player would have fit in well with the team regardless of how well they play.
2. I don’t think specific high-end players are needed – we are stacked with high-end guys on the blue line and have excellent, even enviable, talent in the forward corps. Our issues were on display during the first 4 games – cleanly getting the puck out of the D-zone being one of them and not giving up so many Grade-A because of whoopsies. A higher-end player will not help that.
1) As mentioned previously I would have like landing PLD. Still, not worth rehashing.
2) The Canes do need more higher end talent. I will continue my mantra: develop, develop, develop.
Necas was drafted one spot ahead of Nick Suzuki (most thought he wouldn’t be available when the Canes drafted in 2017). A few Czech players have significantly increased production the season they were 22—Vrana, Hertl, Krejci. I usually think comparisons based solely on nationality are weak; this one might be as well. But I think Necas demonstrated last season that he has high end skills. Let’s hope he is given the role to use them.
Due to Dubois and Laine the conversation focuses on forwards. But several teams have seen high end contributions from D-men (not referring to the elite level of Hughes, Makar, Heiskanan). Think Fox and Girard. Wouldn’t it be nice if the Canes had a young D who could contribute 35+ points?
I, for one, think some patience is in order! (Rare for me)…
This year has been soooo short for the Canes… nobody really knows what they are? I’m going to be in the camp of “let them play”, then evaluate later! They say “patience is a virtue”!!
1). No. Top line type young players don’t hit the market often, and when they do, proceed with caution. Most top line young players are developed within. Double down on player development, bring the young guys along and give them opportunities.
With the uncertainties around the salary cap, and star players to re-sign, a few team -friendly ELCs would be doubly beneficial.
2) A high-end goalie wouldn’t hurt, but that takes cap space.